Date	Ernest Willcox Challenge Cup	Charles Allmand Memorial Shield	Call Change Trophy
1972	Shrewsbury
1973	Shrewsbury
1974	Shrewsbury
1975	Shrewsbury
1976	Shrewsbury
1977	Chetwynd
1978	Wellington
1979	Shrewsbury
1980	Shrewsbury
1981	Shifnal
1982	Shifnal
1983	Shifnal
1984	Shrewsbury	Edgmond
1985	Shrewsbury	Madeley
1986	Shrewsbury	Wellington
1987	Shrewsbury	Edgmond
1988	Shrewsbury	Ightfield and Calverhall
1989	Shrewsbury	Bromfield
1990	Shrewsbury	Tong
1991	Edgmond	Shrewsbury 'B'
1992	Edgmond	Hodnet
1993	Tong	Shifnal	Edgmond
1994	Edgmond	Ryton	Hodnet
1995	Suspended	Suspended	Suspended
1996	Edgmond	Tong	Bridgnorth
1997	Edgmond	Shrewsbury	No entrants
1998	Edgmond	Meole Brace	Great Ness
1999	Edgmond	Hodnet	Prees
2000	Edgmond	Newport	Newport
2001	Shrewsbury	Albrighton	Albrighton
2002	Edgmond	Shifnal	Newport
2003	Shrewsbury	Newport	Newport
2004	Shrewsbury	Not presented	Newport
2005	Shrewsbury 'B'	Baschurch	Baschurch
2006	Edgmond	Upton Magna	Shrewsbury 'A'
2007	Edgmond	Market Drayton	Newport
2008	Shrewsbury 'A'	Baschurch	Shrewsbury 'B'

The Ernest Willcox Challenge Cup is awarded to the band with the fewest faults.

The Call Change Trophy is awarded to the call change band with the fewest faults.

The Charles Allmand Memorial Shield is awarded to the best placed of the other towers which has not won any of the three awards in the previous two competitions.

The remaining rules are normally published in the annual report. The rather arcane requirements for winning the Charles Allmand Shield are designed to enable less experienced bands to gain some success. The fact that seventeen Association towers have so far been awarded one of the trophies is an indication of the success of this ambition.